The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) recently decided that if you're a small-time investor — meaning you hold less than $5 million in shares — you're too small to have a public opinion. Specifically, they yanked access to EDGAR, the government's filing system, where investors used to air their grievances on everything from climate action to company leadership.
But here's the thing about silencing people: sometimes they just build a louder platform. Enter the Proxy Open Exchange, or POE, a shiny new digital soapbox where activist investors are now, quite literally, fighting back.
The Internet, Because Of Course
The SEC's January decree basically said, "If you want to talk about corporate governance, do it quietly." Previously, EDGAR was the go-to for "exempt solicitations" — documents where investors shared their take on a company's direction. The SEC's reasoning? Something about reducing government scope and easing regulations. Also, unnamed companies apparently worried about "misuse causing confusion among investors." Because apparently, investors can't handle a little public discourse.
We're a new kind of news feed.
Regular news is designed to drain you. We're a non-profit built to restore you. Every story we publish is scored for impact, progress, and hope.
Start Your News DetoxAndrew Behar, CEO of shareholder advocacy group As You Sow, wasn't having it. He spearheaded POE, declaring that if the SEC was going to shut down EDGAR, they'd just build their own version. And build it they did.
In less than a week, POE had 63 filings. For context, EDGAR only saw 39 total exempt solicitations for the entire year of 2026. Let that satisfying number sink in. The SEC, for its part, has remained conspicuously silent on POE's sudden existence.
POE works just like EDGAR, even using the same central index keys for identification. As You Sow checks for basic errors, but it's an open forum — all viewpoints welcome. As Tim Smith, a senior policy advisor for the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, put it, it's an "adventurous way for people of all views to post their solicitations" — whether they're pushing for climate action or, say, challenging diversity initiatives.
Jill Fisch, a business law professor at the University of Pennsylvania, notes that POE filings still have to play by the same anti-fraud rules as EDGAR. So, no making things up. But she also points out POE's interface is "much more user-friendly" than the government's "old and glitchy" site. Which, if you think about it, is both impressive and slightly terrifying.
The Cat's Out of the Bag
Not everyone's on board just yet. One of the biggest proxy advisors, ISS, won't touch information not on the official EDGAR platform. They declined to comment, naturally. But Fisch sees huge potential for mutual funds, smaller institutions, and universities to jump on the POE bandwagon.
The real show, though, will be watching how corporations react. Will an Exxon Mobil see POE as a threat and try to launch its own platform? Or will the sheer existence of these alternatives push companies to beg the SEC to just send everyone back to EDGAR? The irony would be delicious.
Behar hopes POE is just a temporary fix, that a future administration will restore EDGAR's open access. But Fisch has a different take. Once investors realize how easy it is to use the internet and social media for communication, she says, "the cat's out of the bag." And you know how hard it is to put a cat back in a bag, especially one that just found its voice.
